Quill and Quire

REVIEWS

« Back to
Book Reviews

No Orchids for Andrea!

by Chrystine Brouillet, Nathalie Gagnon, illus., Linda Gaboriau, trans.

After their recent success in unravelling enigmatic Oriental secrets in The Chinese Puzzle, Andrea and Arthur move on to botanical skullduggery in the second in a new mystery series by Quebec writer Chrystine Brouillet. Andrea, 12, and still no fan of broccoli, is again narrator and dedicated sleuth. Her friend, the hyper-relaxed Arthur, supplies technical support and reality checks. Endearingly, both continue to find the real world much more fascinating than any virtual one. Andrea’s interest in orchids is economic: she wants to grow something valuable to earn money for her father’s birthday gift. The suspicious goings-on that she and Arthur uncover in the orchid world, however, seem to be motivated more by glory than cash. The young sleuths become deeply embroiled in a coterie of orchid zealots with names like Trevor, Godfrey, and Professor Cavendish and past lives that sound like they once intersected with Indiana Jones. Detection proceeds at a dizzying clip, complicated by disguises, double disguises, Black Pearl orchids, vanilla, and red herrings.

Lively, zany, and slight, No Orchids for Andrea! has a telegraphic breathlessness augmented abundantly with exclamation marks. Nothing here is quite what it seems: good guys turn out to be bad and bad ones good. One of the good guys, Arthur’s chess partner, is a recidivist thief whose defence is that he’s doing it for his girlfriend, Nancy, seriously ill with cancer. This tends to blur the story’s moral lines in a slightly unsettling way and brings in a jarring note of real-world problems. But these characters have interesting possibilities, and Brouillet may be keeping them up her sleeve for a sequel. There are a few loose ends – like Andrea’s non-resident dad’s birthday, for example, never given a second thought after the first page. But this throwaway, flyaway style is part of the book’s charm. So are Gagnon’s witty illustrations (Andrea with a frizzy mop of hair, Arthur in backwards baseball cap), perfectly matched with the book’s tongue-in-chic.

 

Reviewer: Maureen Garvie

Publisher: Ragweed

DETAILS

Price: $6.95

Page Count: 96 pp

Format: Paper

ISBN: 0-921556-62-4

Released: Sept.

Issue Date: 1996-11

Categories: Children and YA Fiction

Age Range: ages 8–12